followthemedia.com - a knowledge base for media professionals
Big Business
Recently in Big Business

Wings over Bulgaria
...Emmis International announced its Bulgarian expansion...

Is There Anyone Out There Who Still Thinks This Is All Cyclical?
A media analyst for Credit Suisse put the cat among the pigeons...

Liquidity, liquidity, come, please, to my door
The final billion euro media deal of the year...

AGENDA

All Things Digital
This digital environment

Big Business
Media companies and their world

Brands
Brands and branding, modern and post

The Commonweal
Media associations and institutes

Conflict Zones
Media making a difference

Fit To Print
The Printed Word and the Publishing World

Lingua Franca
Culture and language

Media Rules and Rulers
Media politics

The Numbers
Watching, listening and reading

The Public Service
Public Service Broadcasting

Show Business
Entertainment and entertainers

Sports and Media
Rights, cameras and action

Spots and Space
The Advertising Business

Write On
Journalism with a big J

Send ftm Your News!!
news@followthemedia.com

If You want A Prime Example Of How Not To Run A Media Company Then Take A Look At The UK’s Virgin Media Where The Big Question Is, As Its American CEO Abruptly Quits, Who Actually Runs The Show?

Don’t you just love those stories where the CEO abruptly quits for personal and family reasons, getting a huge payoff including a non-compete clause, and then the media defines “personal” as meaning the man was absolutely fed up with his chairman and vice-versa. That it should happen as the company is trying to sell itself is not exactly what one would call good timing.

Virgin Media logoThus another in a long string of shots in the foot from Virgin Media, the UKs second largest  pay TV operator with 3.4 million TV subscribers (Sky has more than double).  The company had put itself up for sale in July after it has received an approach from the Carlyle private equity group and valuations were put at around £11 billion ($23 billion, €16 billion) with John Malone’s Liberty Media said to be interested before everything came to a screeching halt with the subprime crisis drying up credit.

Virgin has been in a very public row with BSkyB, the country’s largest TV pay operator and the squabble resulted in Sky withdrawing three channels from Virgin’s basic service. That in turn caused some 40,000 cable customers to walk away from Virgin in the last quarter alone because of the dispute plus another 30,000 who left for assorted reasons (customer service continues to be a real problem). Virgin is suing Sky but it’s unlikely the case will go to court until the middle of next year.

Virgin also yelled loud and long to the government when Sky in December swooped a 17.7% stake in ITV, the country’s largest commercial terrestrial broadcaster, basically putting an end to Virgin Media’s thoughts of buying  Britain’s largest commercial terrestrial broadcaster. Sir Richard Branson, Virgin Media’s largest shareholder holding a 10.5% stake has powerful political connections and he yelled “foul” to whomever would listen. The whole issue is now in the hands of the competition authorities, who also took a stab at the Murdoch-controlled Sky by saying they would investigate whether that empire has too much influence and sway in the UK’s plurality of news.

ftm background

If You Want To Know The Future Of Television Then Look No Further Than The Announcements The UK’s BBC and ITV Made This Week; Going Are The Days Of Switching On The “Box” Just To See What’s On!
On-Demand television via the Internet is what the UK public wants and on-demand is what the UK’s largest broadcasters are going to give them, and mostly for free. The BBC Trust (basically the board of directors) gave the BBC the go-ahead for its system this week, and not to be outdone ITV, the largest commercial broadcaster, announced a £20 million makeover of its website so it can provide all of its channels not only streamed, but also video-on-demand including archived shows.

It is a Fight to the Death : Branson v. Murdoch
When Big Media turns to the courts and the regulators to arbitrate business negotiations it’s clear that the consolidation cycle is turning down.

BSkyB Agrees To Pay An Average £4.76 million ($8.9 million) to Televise Exclusively, Including Broadband, Each of 92 UK Premier League Football Matches Per Season From 2007 – 2010, But Mobile Operators Say Football Is Getting Too Expensive For Their Tastes
The UK’s Premier League has just sold domestic television and broadband rights to its matches in 2007 –2010 to BSkyB and Irish broadcaster Setanta for a total of £1.706 billion ($3.27 billion) – a 60% premium over the last deal won exclusively by Sky in 2003.

Virgin’s Deal In the UK To Become A Quadruple Player – Fixed Lines, Mobile, Broadband, and Television – Is A Forerunner of What Will Occur Elsewhere. And Suddenly BSkyB Has A Real Program Competitor On Its Hands -- Watch Those Sports Rights!
It’s the kind of deal that, when announced, seemed such a natural, and it propels Sir Richard Branson yet again into the limelight, this time as the biggest shareholder in a company that will deliver broadband to 2.5 million customers, that already has 4.3 million fixed-line accounts, more than five million mobile customers and 3.3 million cable TV subscribers.

CEO Steve Burch joined NTL, as Virgin Media was then, in January, 2006, and saw through its merger with competitor Telewest Global. Then he oversaw the purchase of Branson’s Virgin Mobile Holdings with the company later taking the Virgin name with Branson as its largest shareholder. It seemed on paper as though it was ideally positioned to make a killing, being able to offer four full services from one supplier on a single bill: TV, fixed-line phones, mobile, and broadband internet. But paper and reality are two different things, and it just didn’t work out as the company thought, and it wasn’t only because of the dispute with Sky.

For instance, its broadband customer base grew, but at only half the rate of such rivals as BT, Carphone Warehouse, and, yes, Sky.  Revenue also increased, but the margin on each customer fell because the loss of Sky programming forced the company to offer high-value customers cut-price deals so they wouldn’t leave, too. The company spent some £25 million ($50 million, €37 million) on rebranding including Uma Thurman TV spots, but for all of that, the numbers were just not what they should have been.

Something very wrong was going on, and James Harding, business editor of The Times, summed it up: “It was not Mr. Burch’s management that caused these problems as much as the fact that he was not allowed to manage. Virgin Media is paying the price for a breakdown in corporate governance.”

He also scathingly noted, “The management at Britain’s largest cable company operator has, over the years, distinguished itself in two regards: extraordinary internal dysfunction and undeserved personal payouts. While subscribers have complained of poor service, and investors have fretted about huge debts (some £6 billion, $12 billion, €8.8 billion), a handful of executives seem to have squabbled over everything except how they should be handsomely rewarded.”

Most of the UK media seemed to buy the company’s spin that the parting was amicable and there were few internal differences in opinion between senior management, but The Times begged to differ.  Dan Sabbagh, media editor, said the problem was that Chairman Jim Mooney was making all of the key strategic decisions from New York and Bill Huff, a large investor who also chaired the executive committee and who actually recruited Mooney as chairman, was also daily poking his fingers into who got hired and what got spent.

According to Sabbagh, CEO Burch was, at best, probably third in the decision hierarchy, and there are few CEOs who can operate well in such an environment. And none of that is new to Virgin. Burch was recruited to replace CEO Simon Duffy who was moved into the non-role of executive deputy chairman because it was said at the time he also had disputes with the Huff/Mooney axis.

But don’t feel too sorry for Burch. On the job for just 18 months he walks with a lump sum payment of two years’ salary -- £750,000 ($1.5 million, €1.1 million) - and he has been vested in the 250,000 shares previously awarded and that are worth just shy of £3 million ($6 million, €4.4 million).  And all is niceness in the public statement from his nemesis, Mooney. “Steve has contributed significantly to the transformation of Virgin Media.”

Harding, The Time’s Business Editor, said Burch’s departure is not going to solve the problems at Virgin Media. “The fundamental management problem is not on the executive floor in London, but at the board level in New York.”


copyright ©2004-2007 ftm partners, unless otherwise noted Contact UsSponsor ftm