- a knowledge base for media professionals
New This Week

Hot topics click link for more

Search / Email Story / Print Page /
Username: Password:
forgot your password?
If you have never registered for ftm
please click here
The Tickle File
short takes on daily media news

Trade deal spooks public broadcasters
book prices not affected

Multinational trade negotiations are complex and delicate. Years are invested in ironing out differences, which often make the negotiations more salient than any end result. The European Commission and the United States government jointly declared as negotiations began in spring 2013 that the free-trade agreement known as the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) would be good for business and consumers on both side of the Atlantic with the dismantling of protectionism.

Now that the US and Pacific Rim nations have completed the similar Transpacific Partnership agreement (TPP) after more than five years of negotiations, TTIP is getting more attention. European critics worry that their side is at a distinct disadvantage. Virtually every area of possible trade and commerce is “on the table,” from food and agriculture products to information technology and automobiles. European dismay with US media-tech giants from Amazon and Facebook to Google will be pitted against the current little problem with German carmaker Volkswagen’s deceit on emissions testing in the US.

Cultural issues continue to irritate European critics. Even though the audiovisual sector was stripped from TTIP negotiations last year, French government insistence prevailing, the trade association of European public broadcasters European Broadcasting Union (EBU) is calling “for the protection of cultural diversity and the principle of technological neutrality to be included explicitly in the final text,” said an EBU statement (October 8). (See complete EBU statement here) The fear, of course, is that without explicit text exempting the special, often favorable, relationships between EU Member States and their public broadcasters could be dismantled as unfair competition.

"Economic constraints and increasing consolidation in our sector is placing ever greater pressure on the unique role of public service media in Europe,” said EBU President Jean-Paul Philippot in the statement. “We need to make crystal clear that securing a deal on services under TTIP cannot be at the expense of our cultural heritage and values.”

Separately, German Economic Affairs Minister Sigmar Gabriel and Culture Minister Monika Grütters reiterated the need to “continue to allow regulations that promote the diversity of culture and language as well as of the media; freedom and protection,” in a joint statement (October 8) (See statement here - in German) The greater concern is the oft mentioned provision allowing companies to demand compensation for losses through “unfair” national regulations.

“Public funding of museums, theaters or operas and for audiovisual media will still be possible,” explained Minister Gabriel. “The protection of and opportunity to promote cultural diversity are guaranteed. Fixed book prices are not affected by TTIP. The cultural and media diversity and the promotion of culture in Germany are not jeopardized by the agreement.”

Doldrums over, media investment takes a leap
“European groups undervalued”

Raising money has always been the special provenance of folks with a knack for raising money. As the media sector, broadly, reconstitutes after the last digital wave the world is awash with opportunities. Money, it’s said, never sleeps.

Dabbling in a variety of media investments over the recent few years, Mathieu Pigasse and Xavier Niel - vice chairman of investment bank Lazard Europe and founder/principal shareholder of French ISP and mobile operator Free - stirred the pot this week announcing a fund raising project with TV producer Pierre-Antoine Capton. The investment fund, called Media One, reported Le Figaro (October 5), is a SPAC - special purpose acquisition company - designed to allow private equity investors to raise cash effectively dedicated to a particular - and large - acquisition. JP Morgan Investment Bank has been hired to deal with the details of placing the offering, expected between €300 and €500 million, 75% of which goes to the primary acquisition. M.Capton will be running the business. (See more about media in France here)

In recent months French telecom billionaire Patrick Drahi acquired newspapers Libération and L’Express, majority holding in French broadcaster NextRadioTV and significant majority in US cable operator Suddenlink. Vincent Bolloré’s Vivendi has solidified its position in pay-TV operator Canal+ as well as taking a significant stake in Telecom Italia and buying a French TV production house. Last week Groupe Figaro, publisher of Le Figaro and a subsidiary of industrial giant Dassault, acquired online publishing specialist CCM Benchmark.

Where the will go, quite naturally, is the object of intense speculation. Pigasse and Niel - along with YSL Group founder Pierre Bergé - became majority shareholders in the Le Monde publishing house in 2010 and French daily Nouvel Observateur last year. In May M.Pigasse acquired Radio Nova. Indications are, according to Le Figaro, main interests are in publishing, radio, internet and TV production.

The first big acquisition may not be French, the ultimate break-up of Lagardére Active still widely anticipated. These media investors are “judging European groups undervalued compared with the US,” said Le Monde (October 7). Maybe in Italy, Spain or elsewhere; opportunities abound.

Media groups want protection from extremists
no longer acceptable

Complaints from supporters of fringe and, often, extremist views are part of daily life in the news media. Facts and logic, not to forget civility, can disrupt a certain worldview. Never satisfied, complaints metastasize and violence ensues.

In a joint statement, public broadcaster Mitteldeutsche Rundfunk (MDR), German Journalists Association (DJV) and Saxony Federation of Newspaper Publishers urged authorities in three eastern States - Saxony, Saxony-Anhalt and Thuringia - to “finally decide to confront the specter,” reported Die Zeit (October 6). Last week, reporters for MDR and newspaper Dresdner Neueste Nachrichten were physically attacked by followers of the xenophobic Pegida movement at a rally in Dresden. The recent influx of refugees arriving in Germany has fueled new demonstrations by Dresden-based Pegida and Leipzig-based Legida, almost entirely in eastern Germany. With little sympathy in the rest of Germany, Pegida followers continue to refer to news media as “Lügenpresse" - lying press. (See more about press/media freedom here)

“In spite of verbal attacks, the media are always ready to report factually and objectively,” said the statement. “The ongoing ‘Lügenpresse’ calls make for a poisoned climate, which is no longer acceptable. We expect the Ministries of Interior and police prevent attacks on journalists.”

Big brands are all media brands now
“same information ecosystem”

There’s a certain magic to brand strength. Having it attracts the pixie dust of consumer love and adoration. Losing it, well, means other dust is soon to follow. Interbrand released this week its assessment of the world’s most valuable brands. Without surprise, technology brands are on top, fast rising and almost every one attached in some way to media.

The Apple brand is, for the third year, the world’s most valuable, estimated by Interbrand at US$170.276 billion, a year to year increase of 43%. Its smartphones and tablets are everywhere, still very cool and through the miracle of mobile technology deliver all kinds of media content. The Apple Music streaming service is among several changing the way people listen to their favorite tunes, to the growing anguish of radio broadcasters. Apple recently upgraded the iPhone operating system facilitating ad blocking applications, to the groans of online publishers and ad buyers.

Holding steady at number two is Google, valued at US$ 120.314 billion, up 12%. The company known as Google isn’t quite the same this week, restructured as Alphabet, a holding company containing Google - the search engine and advertising medium - as a subsidiary. Robots, drones and other high-tech investments are, in a way, separate platforms, freed from the old “don’t be evil” motto. (See more about Google here)

Facebook’s brand value grew most among Interbrand’s list of 100, 54% one year on to US$22.03 billion and 23rd ranking. The social media and ad selling platform began hosting “native” content from publishers, users now skipping the branded online portals of others. The European Court of Justice (CoJ) invalidated “safe harbor” agreements allowing Facebook and other US tech companies from transferring data from Europe to the US for processing or, so its believed, evil. Brand value will quite likely be unaffected.

Pure (nearly) media brands are few and far between on Interbrand’s hot 100. Disney ranks 13th at US$ 36.514 billion, up 13%. Thomson-Reuters fell 12% to US$6.583 billion, ranking 63rd. “We recognize that technology companies and news organizations are part of the same information ecosystem,” said Google chief legal officer Dave Drummond at the June Global Editor’s Forum in Barcelona.

Local music gaining politician’s attention, quotas rise
will the audience follow?

For commercial broadcasters rules establishing quotas for music performed in the national language and produced locally always raise a certain level of discomfort. With streaming services offering music fans an alternative to traditional broadcast radio music quotas are seen as audience threatening. But in many national markets music quotas find support from local artists and producers who fear threats to their livelihoods. Cultural agencies and government ministries tend to dismiss the former and support the latter.

After many months of debate the Slovak parliament settled on changes to broadcasting rules establishing music quotas. Beginning in 2016 private-sector radio stations will be required to broadcast music at least 20% performed, written or produced by a Slovak national, reported (October 1). The quota rises to 25% in 2017. Oh, Slovak content is calculated from 6 in the morning through midnight to prevent dumping during the all-night show.

As the Slovak parliament began its debate earlier this year, pop/dance music channel Europa 2 attempted to raise outrage among its listeners. "We do not want to play what someone else commands,” said the promo, reported by Stratégie (April 17). “We want to play maximum music that appeals to us and you.” Politicians were not fazed.

Public broadcaster RTVS, operating five national radio channels, will be complying with a greater music content quota, 35%. The new rule does not differentiate radio music formats.

Reorganization plan for public broadcasting rejected
“extremely expensive in the short term”

There’s nothing like reorganizing. French public broadcasters, the politicians who love them and those who don’t are, again, wrestling with plans to overhaul the respectfully described unwieldy array of media services all or part funded by French taxpayers. Last week two members of the French Senate presented a plan to combine all of it into a single entity by 2020 because “their economic model is going through a serious crisis.”

That proposal would create France Médias, which media watchers dubbed “BBC à la française” - French BBC, referring to UK public broadcaster BBC. A few weeks ago new France Télévisions CEO Delphine Ernotte made a more modest proposal to create with Radio France a combined news operation. French public broadcasting currently includes France Télévisions, Radio France, a share in culture channel Arte, international TV broadcaster France 24 and international radio broadcaster Radio France International (RFI). (See more about media in France here)

“This idea of a French BBC is a recurring suggestion,” huffed Culture and Communication Minister Fleur Pellerin to Le Figaro (October 2). “This model undoubtedly is a source of inspiration for French public broadcasting. It would perhaps enable savings in the long term but this type of reform, which would ultimately recreate the ORTF, is extremely expensive in the short term.”

ORTF - Office de Radiodiffusion Télévision Française - was the government agency formed in 1964 to organize French state radio and TV broadcasting into a single entity largely to fight off early private sector intrusion. ORTF was reorganized out of business in 1974.

Minister Pellerin has a forceful voice in French media policy. On the proposal to consolidate all French public media, she offered a succinct verdict: “I think not.”

From Last Weeks ftm Tickle File

EU quandary affects press freedom

Dissing the European Union and its institutions is surfeit from some quarters and increasingly so. There are calls for it or them or somebody to do something about, well, anything. And others want same to do less. It must be painful paddling around the Berlaymont these days wearing those targets.

This week the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) fired its volley at the EU and many of its Member States. The report - Balancing Act (September 29) - authored by the organizations EU correspondent Jean-Paul Marthoz recommended holding Member States to established law; Treaty on European Union Article 2 and 11, Charter of Fundamental Rights. Freedom of expression, freedom of the press and tenets of media pluralism are all included in the founding documents and European Union institutions could do more, said the report’s recommendations, to “hold Member States” responsible for keeping to their commitments. (See more about press/media freedom here).

Also recommended is the hammer: “Utilize Article 7 and the suspension of voting rights against Member States that break press freedom commitments…”. The report itself faults EU institutions for “high-minded” ignorance of breaches in press freedom. Mexico and Syria are worse, no? The EU sat on its institutional hands during the Berlusconi years. Now there are worries about the UK with leading politicians, encouraged by certain media proprietors, embracing withdrawal from the EU altogether.

Now, nothing is done about the Hungarian government under Prime Minister Viktor Orban. “The EU presumed that once admitted, Member States would never backtrack,” said the CPJ report. “So the Commission, as guardian of the treaties, found itself under-equipped in dealing with Hungary.” The demise of media freedom in PM Orban’s Hungary has been well-documented by international media, prompting authorities to react in not-so-subtle ways. The report recalled the AP cameraman filming refugees crossing into Hungary being set upon by police dogs and forced to delete the video. (See more about media in Hungary here)

The five countries formally in the EU accession framework - Albania, FYR Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia and Turkey - were also called out. “None has a respectable press freedom record,” said the CPJ report. After the admission of Bulgaria and Romania - both notable backsliders - the EU pushed for legislative reform in Croatia on issues involving media freedom. The next new EU Member States - if any - will also need to adjust.

“The history of European integration, however, taught them that political or economic expediency may trump values.”

No cartoons todaybr> “incalcuable consequences”

It was an experiment to demonstrate the negative effects of self-censorship, explained the editor in charge. Ten years ago - September 30, 2005 - a dozen cartoons, some depicting the Prophet Muhammad, were published by Danish newspaper Morgenavisen Jyllands-Posten (JP). And so began, arguably, a grand and yet contentious debate within the media community, cultural leaders, politicians and the public at large pitting religious sensitivity affront freedom of expression.

“Modern, secular society is rejected by some Muslims,” wrote culture editor Flemming Rose to accompany the cartoons. “They demand a special position, insisting on special consideration of their own religious feelings. It is incompatible with contemporary democracy and freedom of speech, where one must be ready to put up with insults, mockery and ridicule. It is certainly not always attractive and nice to look at, and it does not mean that religious feelings should be made fun of at any price, but that is of minor importance in the present context. We are on our way to a slippery slope where no-one can tell how the self-censorship will end.” (See more about press/media freedom here)

Media outlets in Denmark, noting the anniversary, are not republishing those cartoons. “We see no reason for it,” said Ekstra Bladet chief editor Poul Madsen, quoted by Danish public broadcaster DR (September 30). “Everybody knows them and it would just be an empty provocation.” (See more about media in Denmark here)

“They are iconic and symbolic,” said Berlingske Tidende chief editor Lisbeth Knudsen. “It could have incalculable consequences if we showed them.”

Jyllands-Posten republished the original page without illustration or comment. Flemming Rose, now JP foreign editor, revisited the debate recently saying, “No drawing is worth a human life.”

Much has changed in the last decade.

Previous weeks complete Tickle File

Week of October 5 2015

In Write On

Reality, News And A Digital Migration
phone on the road Refugees trying to flee civil war and terror in Syria, Iraq and on to Central Asia and North Africa became through this past summer the significant focus for news media. One tragedy after another led the headlines and breaking news reports. Explaining it all tested the skills of journalists and editors, lest xenophobic opinion crowd out reality. There has been considerable new learning.

Encore Une Fois - This Week Last Year in Reaching Out

More Internet, More Information; Some Good, Some Not
faster and faster The relationship between internet technology and critical information is largely beneficial. The public’s interest is quickly satisfied by words and pictures flowing instantly from the miracle of the digital age. News cycles, though, hate vacuums and the web tends to neutralize value.



Encore Une Fois - This Week Last Year in Lingua Franca

Politician Attacks “Crazy Loopholes”
look inside Quotas legally requiring radio broadcasters to broadcast music locally produced or performed in a national language periodically rise to broad debate. The music industry generally loves the idea and radio broadcasters generally hate it. Supporters and critics often cite French and Canadian music content broadcasting laws as proving their respective points.


new ftm Knowledge

We've Gone Mobile - And Nothing's The Same – new

Consumers have taken to smartphones in huge numbers. Competition among device makers, telecoms and content producers has created an insatiable demand. With so much volume markets are fragmenting... and nothing's the same. 152 pages PDF (August 2015)

Order here


The BBC – new

Few pure media brands transcend borders and boundries to acheive the iconic status of the BBC. The institution has come to define public service broadcasting. Yet missteps, errors and judgment questions fuel critics. The BBC battles those critics and competitors and, sometimes, itself. 155 pages PDF (August 2015)

Order here


Europe's Radio - Southern Europe

Radio broadcasting in southern Europe ranges from highly developed to developing highly. Italian, Spanish and Portuguese radio is unique, creative and very popular. Radio in Croatia, Serbia and Greece has had ups and downs. The ftm Knowledge file includes Resources. 126 pages PDF (June 2015)

Order here


Google Is... Still

Google's leaders say their goal is to change the world. And they have. Far more than a search engine, Google has impact over every media sector and beyond, from consumer behavior to broadcasting and advertising to newspapers. That impact is detailed in this ftm Knowledge file. 116 pages PDF (April 2015)

Order here

Become an ftm Individual or Corporate Member and order Knowledge files at no charge. JOIN HERE!

ftm Knowledge files are available to non-Members at €49 each.

new ftm Resources

...more Resources...



Inside ftm

Who reads ftm?
Financial institutions, European institutions and NGOs, media companies (public and private), the digital world, news agencies, regulators, educational institutions, measurement services and, of course, the advertising people are on the list of ftm subscribers, Members and sponsors. Are you?


Get noticed with ftm !!

Add ftm content to your website, newsletter or publication. Lift your next meeting or conference with ftm documents or presentations. Click here for details.
For reprint or republishing needs or questions, please contact us.

ftm Members LinkedIn Group

ftm Members can now join the FollowTheMedia LinkedIn Group and discover a broad array of new features for expanding your own network. LinkedIn is without question the world’s premiere web-based professional networking platform.

Visit this link to JOIN ftm or contact us by email

ftm Radio Page NEW

Friday October 9, 2015
radio in Slovakia, music quotas, Europa 2, RTVS

Recently in ftm...

In Big Business

chilly wind


We're Having An Opportunity Here So Please Don't Get In The Way



There’s No Time Like The Present So Get On With It

Investors Cut The Cord On Traditional TV


In Spots & Space

dancing ants


Block And Tackle, Dance And Tumble




All Very Unconventional From The Sound Of It

Ads Off, Except For Beer; Reality Conditional


In Lingua Franca

radio dial


Broadcasters Celebrated For Good Works




Digital Culture Always Online And Always in A Hurry

Politician Attacks “Crazy Loopholes”


In The Public Service

mysterious M


Dial M For Mysterious






In The Digital Age There Is No Zero-sum Game

Separating Progress From Horizontal Motion


In Fit To Print

happy money


Ideas Grow - Money Flows






Being The Boss Is No Picnic

Less Is More Not A Media-Tech Concept


In The Numbers

crystal ball mobile


This Crystal Ball Looks Like A Tiny Screen




Research Methods Adjusted, Little Blood Letting

Scaring Them Away Does Just That


In Sports & Media

salad daysPeanuts For Traditional TV, Salad Days For Pay-TV



TV Sports Defies Gravity, Heat And Friction

No Efficiencies Found In Sports Broadcasting, Only A Deep Hole


In Media Rules & Rulers



Consternation Befits The Independent Regulator



Court Chases Anonymous Trolls Back Under Bridge

What Is What And When It's Not


In Write On

cookie recipe


Mind The Cookie - Trade Secrets Are Recipes Until Leaked





Big Stories Always Upset Somebody. It's Great!!

Bad Times For Reporters Only Gets Worse


In All Things Digital

oh, it is


The Message Is Money And It All Sounds Cool




Brand Building Is A Strategy, Extracting Profits A Tactic

Digital Future Just A Shout Away


In Show Biz

is it live?


Absolutely Live And Right Now






Were You One Of The Few Who Didn't Watch THE Wedding?

April 29, 2011, Westminster Abbey! Oh, What A Royal Media Circus For The Next Five Months And Beyond


In Brands and Branding

the envelopeIf Viewers Aren't Excited The Rest Doesn't Matter


Box Opened, Tentacles Appear, Everybody’s Entertained

Games Changers And Media Killers


In Reaching Out

Christiane AmanpourOld Waves Across Borders Fade – New Waves Rise



Market Development Struggles Between Waiting And Wanting

More Internet, More Information; Some Good, Some Not


ftm newsletters

ftm newsletters update leading media news twice monthly.
Sign-up here

copyright ©2004-2015 ftm partners, unless otherwise noted

Contact UsSponsor ftm