followthemedia.com - a knowledge base for media professionals
Fit To Print
KNOWLEDGE

Mobile Media
November 2006

ftm analyzes the growth of mobile media. Who and what are the driving forces? Where and when will mobile media truly emerge? 60 pages PDF file

Free to ftm members and others from €39

Order

The State of the Print Media in the World
October 2006

ftm reports from the World Association of Newspapers Congresses. Includes WAN readership studies, Russian media and Russian politics, press freedom and the state of journalism. 62 pages. PDF file

Free to ftm members and others from €39

Order

AGENDA

All Things Digital
This digital environment

Big Business
Media companies and their world

Brands
Brands and branding, modern and post

The Commonweal
Media associations and institutes

Conflict Zones
Media making a difference

Fit To Print
The Printed Word and the Publishing World

Lingua Franca
Culture and language

Media Rules and Rulers
Media politics

The Numbers
Watching, listening and reading

The Public Service
Public Service Broadcasting

Show Business
Entertainment and entertainers

Sports and Media
Rights, cameras and action

Spots and Space
The Advertising Business

Write On
Journalism with a big J

Send ftm Your News!!
news@followthemedia.com

Those Newspaper Publishers Who Believe It’s Business As Usual and January Means A 6% Hike In Advertising Rates Had Better Think Again

It’s a cycle that sees no end. Circulation drops, costs rise, revenues are flat and yet the business needs to maintain its 20% plus margins. But thankfully January is just around the corner so its fallback time -- raise those 2007 advertising rates by some 6%. But this time there’s a huge problem ahead -- many advertisers are going to give a whole new definition to the term “playing hardball”.
Go To Follow Up & Comments

Daily BlabFor 2006 many metropolitan US newspapers that had lost circulation saw no reason not to ask for 6% increases. USA Today went for 6%.(see comment) And with few and far between exceptions most metropolitan newspaper have reported their 2006 advertising numbers less than 2005. Does it really take an MBA to explain to senior media executives that in this day and age with the Internet snapping away at advertiser’s heels that it is a very difficult sale to charge more for less – unmeasured less at that.

What’s a newspaper like the Boston Globe to do? In 2005 its circulation dropped 8% so it modified its 2006 rate increase, asking only a 3% increase.  This year advertising is down 10.2% for the year, including October’s 11.8% plunge. Daily circulation is down to 414,225 from 451,471 (-8.3%) and Sunday circulation fell below 700,000, from 707,813 to 652,146 (-8.25%).

So, with those kinds of numbers how much of a rate hike do you figure the Globe should be seeking? If you were an advertiser would you not be asking by how much the Globe is going to reduce its rates?

ftm background

News International Expands Its Print, Web, Mobile and New Magazine To Grow All Its Businesses In The UK
Four years ago News International UK newspaper sales during the World Cup grew 6%, “and we didn’t even make the finals,” declared Les Hinton, executive chairman of News International in the UK. “This year we’ll be in the finals so we’re looking to double those extra sales this time around.”

If US Newspapers Think They Have It Bad Then The They Should Look Across The Atlantic -- In the UK Trinity-Mirror Reports Advertising Down 16% At Its Three National Tabloids While Losses At Murdoch’s Times and Sunday Times Treble In The Past Three Years And Associated’s Daily Mail Cuts Some Editorial Budgets By 20%
No matter what spin is put on it, It’s much more than a “cyclical downturn”; the UK national newspaper business has very much the smell of undergoing a major structural change because of severe advertising revenue declines, and it is the loss primarily of classifieds to the Internet that is the villain.

Is There A Correlation Between Internet Advertising Increasing 22% in 2005 While National Newspaper Advertising Dropped 4.7%, And That Some 50 Million Americans Now Turn to the Internet For Their Daily News Fix?
As broadband Internet access increases so will their users turn to the Internet for their daily news requirements, according to significant US research. And since 37% of adult Americans now have broadband compared to 10% four years ago, is it just coincidence that advertising revenue growth for traditional media fell last year while on the Internet it soared 22.3%?

A Clear Internet Message for Traditional Media: Besides Developing Your Own Branded Information Web Site, Buy Whatever Else Is Available On the Web Whether It Has Anything To Do With News or Not!
Three trends are now apparent for traditional media to retrieve lost profits: their own branded web sites are the most popular news destinations for local news, they must invest heavily in new media, and new media doesn’t mean just news and information -- as long as enough unique visitors flock to a site, buy it!

Can A Newspaper or Broadcaster’s Web Site Become Too Popular?
From initially hoping that web news sites would just go away, to then adopting the “if you can’t beat them join them but with as little as possible” strategy to then jumping in with no holds barred, the media has grappled since the Internet began to define its rightful place on the web.

This writer, having negotiated with newspaper publishers over news agency contracts for his entire career, has a great admiration for their negotiating skills and no doubt all of those skills will be brought to the forefront as newspapers talk with their major advertisers about next year’s rates. But those advertisers are already letting it be known that in this downward environment if a publisher gets to keep rates at the status quo, let alone an increase they’ll have done well.

Jouette Travis, an executive vice president and managing director for Carat, recently told the Media Life web site that publishers need to play fair. “If circulation is going significantly south, be careful of rates,” she warns publishers. “They can’t raise rates as they lose circulation.”

And her biggest fear? “That newspapers will try to charge more for advertising. I think it would be smart not to make undue increases. I think newspapers have to be careful about attempting to recoup losses by charging advertisers more against declines in circulation.”

And lest the publisher think that a media buyer has little choice but to continue with the newspaper spend no matter what the rate, then think again.  “I believe the Internet is the fastest-growing medium and outdoor is the second fastest.”

Given all the competition out there, Travis, who has spent the last 20 years buying newspaper space, says, “Above all, they should avoid raising rates and look to how they can fit in long-term.” So there’s that shot across the bow.

The Los Angeles Business Journal says that national and local advertisers are ready to take on the Los Angeles Times if it tries to get smart with its 2007 advertising rates. The recent six-month audit for the Times saw circulation down 8%, although management will argue that was mostly getting rid of bulk copy sales and the like that advertisers aren’t really interested in, anyway.

Macys now wields tremendous power since it has amalgamated so many different department store brands under just the Macy’s umbrella. It is one of the Times’ biggest advertisers and it doesn’t see why advertising rates should go up when circulation has gone down.

“Papers, as general rule, are reluctant to identify the exact relationship of circulation to rates, Mike Monroe, Macy’s vice-president of media and advertising, told the Journal. “As a general rule, newspapers don’t offer decreases in rates. So, whatever rate is paid eventually is something the publisher and the advertiser will agree upon.”

The Times has not issued its 2007 rate card, but advertisers are making it known they are ready for tough negotiations and as far as they are concerned they believe downward circulation should translate into downward advertising rates. To use the shorthand of Internet messaging – lol (lots of luck!).

And it’s not that newspapers are negotiating from a position of strength. Average paid circulation fell 2.8 percent on weekdays and 3.4 percent on Sundays, according to the recent newspaper audit. May’s audit showed average weekday circulation fell 2.5 percent in the six months ending in March, while Sunday circulation fell 3.1 percent, so as the year went on the problems grew worse, and there is nothing to indicate anything will get any better in 2007.

Not only that, but advertisers are getting more and more into the measurability that television and Internet can provide, but which is still very difficult for newspapers. The deck is stacked against publishers except …now is the time to really play the newspaper web site trump card.

If ever there was a time for advertising convergence – packages for web and newspaper – that time is probably right now. Publishers have the figures to show that by combining the readership of the newspaper and its web site then readership is actually up.

The psyche of advertising buyers is that they like to think they are getting something  more for their money, not something less, and so the print/web combination really fits.

That web site just might be worth its weight in gold after all.



ftm Follow Up & Comments

USA TODAY Corrects - December 1, 2006

Steve Anderson, Director of Communications at USA Today, corrected the ad rate increase; 6% rather than 8% reported in the articles' original version.

"We announced in a letter to advertisers a 6% increase for 2006 (and we have done the same for 2007). I believe that we increased 8% for 2005."

copyright ©2004-2006 ftm partners, unless otherwise noted Contact UsSponsor ftm