followthemedia.com - a knowledge base for media professionals
Big Business

Free News On The Internet A Failed Business Model?

The media has been rushing the past few years to put all its breaking news on the Internet for free, and while at it, might as well put the features, investigative pieces, in fact just about everything there! And by golly, Internet readership shot up while print circulation fell. Why buy the newspaper when that news is on the Internet for free? So what that Internet ads are bringing in only 12% of what a print ad does? Could it be that the free news on the internet business model isn’t all it’s cracked up to be, or put another way, is that mirror cracked?

crackedSure, there are a few examples like Norway’s VG where the newspaper web site is close to bringing in the same revenues as print, but such situations globally are really few and far between. Most forecasts say that even in five years time the Internet will provide no more than 13% of total revenue for most newspapers, and that won’t be so much because of increasing web revenues as it will be from decreasing print revenues.

So maybe it ‘s time to take another look at this business model and to do that we turn to a fascinating speech given last week by Walter E. Hussman, Jr., publisher of the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette who spoke at the 62nd annual National Conference of Editorial Writers, and what he said deserves wide dissemination.

The Democrat-Gazette charges for most of its online content, and you know, its print circulation has gone up over the past 10 years – not by much but an increase is far far better than what most newspapers have reported during that period.  Charging for online content is “really contrary to what most people in the industry are doing,” he said. “They’re putting all their content out there thinking they’re going to reap some great bonanza by doing it.”

He compared his small circulation increase (7,500 copies) to two newspapers that are fairing so poorly their owners have put them up for sale -- the Austin American-Statesman (Cox) , where circulation is down by 17, 300 and the San Diego Union-Tribune (Copley) , down  by about 97, 300.

 “These are the kind of newspapers that five years ago would have been a dream for someone to even bid on — both great, great markets,” he said.

So, what is the Democrat-Gazette’s secret to success?  Very simple – people need to buy the newspaper to get most of the content they are looking for. It is not all available for free on the Web. Hussman belongs to the camp that says newspapers will remain viable for readers and advertisers as long as circulation and readership is maintained.

What he can’t compete against is the national and international news that is now a free Internet commodity. If that is what readers mostly want then he’s not going to keep them as print readers. But if the newspaper has something that is not available elsewhere (local news, investigative pieces and the like) then people will continue to pay.

He says flat-out that the banner ads and pop-ups just don’t sell. Online advertising for newspapers, he said, has turned out to be “a flop.” He asked, “Anybody in this room ever gone out and bought something from reading a pop-up ad or a banner ad? I’ve never bought anything,” he told his audience.

Hussman is nothing if not pragmatic. He told Al Neuharth, USA Today founder and former Gannett CEO, in a recent USA Today column that the secret to his newspaper’s continuing success is “We put news in the paper that people can use. We give away free classified ads to help them find a job or sell a car or a house.”

A blog on the site of the weekly Arkansas Times took issue with Hussman’s Internet views, and it also mentioned some extenuating circumstances that helped keep the Press-Democrat circulation firm. But on the free web philosophy the blog basically says that horse is long gone so useless closing that barn door.

“Newspapers have been crippled less by free web content than by the devastating impact of on-line classified advertising. Newspapers' loss of young readers was well underway long before the Internet came along. Charging for web content now -- as a new strategy -- would be a risky move. Many simply won't pay. They'll turn to the growing list of options. TV stations, for example, are becoming one-stop news sites in many markets, with news, weather, sports scores and, some places, even obituaries.

“On the other hand, Hussman can afford as head of a family enterprise to settle for a lower profit margin than corporate media groups with their hungry stockholders and debt loads. Over the long haul, if he's right in running against the tide, his jackpot will be enormous.

“Over the long, long haul (and that haul may be shorter than I think), you have to presume we'll see the end of expensive paper and presses someday.”

Be that as it may, a recent piece by Chicago columnist Phil Kadner says that if the nation’s banking system can be bailed out by the government for making stupid decisions, then why not the newspaper industry. Here’s some of his reasoning in an open letter to President Bush:

“The leaders in our industry have made decisions so incredibly dumb they seem incomprehensible to rank-and-file employees who have absolutely no business sense…Our leaders decided to give away the product we used to sell – making all newspaper stories available for free on the Internet.

“Why are we doing this?” I remember saying years ago. “It’s the future,” I was told. Everyone in the business is doing it. We’re not going to be left behind.” “But how are we going to make money?” I said, not having a head for business. “We’ll figure it out,” I was told,

“Of course, no one has figured it out, and young people no longer are buying newspapers. No one in the newspaper business can figure out why that is. Mr. President, I contend that an industry led by people who give away its product for free, a business that cannot figure out why young people no longer buy a product that’s free, is ripe for a federal bailout.”

Well, at least the business model is now being openly questioned.  Is print just holding out until the Internet can take over, or is there a way for both to live profitably side-by-side?

 

 


related ftm articles:

Media searches for a new business model
The business model you choose depends on where your product/service is on the product life cycle. Media business models by nature must interact with other business models, which are also moving. New business models are rare and disruptive.

WAN Survey Confirms Young Get Their News From Family, Friends, and Social Networking, And, Surprisingly, They Claim To Read Paid-For Newspapers More Than Free Newspapers

Young people get most of their news and information from family and friends and from social networking sources than any other media, according to a new report from the World Association of Newspapers.

Newspapers and Broadcasting Are Still Primary News Sources And Internet News, While Growing in Popularity, Still Just Supplements Most Needs
A new major American survey has loads of good news for those who believe traditional media still has a long healthy life ahead, and it has loads of good news for those that believe the Internet continues to grow in news popularity. But dig into it deep enough to sort it all out and there are signs that for traditional media things may not be getting better, but the worst may be over.


advertisement

ftm resources

no resources posted as of September 26, 2009


ftm Knowledge

Media in Spain - Diverse and Challenged – new

Media in Spain is steeped in tradition. yet challenged by diversity. Publishers hold great influence, broadcasters competing. New media has been slow to rise and business models for all are under stress. Rich in language and culture, Spain's media is reaching into the future and finding more than expected. 123 pages, PDF. January 2018

Order here

The Campaign Is On - Elections and Media

Elections campaigns are big media events. Candidates and issues are presented, analyzed and criticized in broadcast and print. Media is now more of a participant in elections than ever. This ftm Knowledge file reports on news coverage, advertising, endorsements and their effect on democracy at work. 84 pages. PDF (September 2017)

Order here

Fake News, Hate Speech and Propaganda

The institutional threat of fake news, hate speech and propaganda is testing the mettle of those who toil in news media. Those three related evils are not new, by any means, but taken together have put the truth and those reporting it on the back foot. Words matter. This ftm Knowledge file explores that light. 48 pages, PDF (March 2017)

Order here

More ftm Knowledge files here

Become an ftm Individual or Corporate Member to order Knowledge Files at no charge. JOIN HERE!


copyright ©2004-2009 ftm partners, unless otherwise noted Contact UsSponsor ftm