followthemedia.com - a knowledge base for media professionals
Write On

Forget Me Knots And Memory Holes

The digital dividend continues to chill the journalistic air. Online services give too much or too little, attract too many people but far less revenue. Search engines and aggregators are the new street corner kiosks. Libraries store newspapers for hundreds of years or until the paper disintegrates. Nobody goes there in the smartphone age. They go online where nothing is lost or forgotten.

memory holeWhen incredulity passed into reality with the Right To Be Forgotten inscribed permanently into European Union law in 2014, advocates for free speech and the journalism trade were deeply apprehensive. Under the Data Protection Directive, upheld by the European Court of Justice (ECJ), search engines, largely Google due to its global scale and the specific Google Spain case brought to the ECJ, have been required to sever search links to web pages deemed "inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant, or excessive in relation to the purposes for which they were processed.” Online news publishers warned of the public’s right to know being tossed down Orwell’s memory hole, “whirled away on a current of warm air”.

A restive Google, other search engines following, complied grudgingly. Privacy rights, very touchy in Europe’s historical context, demand control over a nosy public empowered digitally. Google, reportedly, has removed from indexing about a half million website links from 1.6 million requests, according to the Columbia Journalism Review (July 26).

Individual governments have pushed extensions to the Right To Be Forgotten. The Rome (Italy) Supreme Court of Causation upheld in June a lower court ruling that requires online news publishers to effectively delete pages after a proscribed length of time, two or two and a half years, noted Guardian News and Media in-house lawyer Athalie Matthews in the Guardian (September 20). Online news portal PrimaDaNoi was fined and ordered to remove a 2008 news item about a stabbing in a restaurant because search results for the restaurant turned up the story, thus, it argued, tainting its reputation. (See more about press freedom here)

"The news story about a knife fight in a restaurant must be removed from the digital archive because despite being correct, telling the truth and not going beyond the limits of the law, produced a detriment to the applicants, that is, the subjects of the story,” said the Court. “The easy accessibility and searchability of the story, exceeding those of printed newspapers, given the widespread distribution of the local online news (portal), allowed from the date of publication until formal notice of Court sufficient time because the news disclosed would have satisfied the public interests underlying the publisher’s journalistic right.” The Rome Court borrowed extensively from the ECJ Google Spain decision. PrimaDaNoi indicated it will pursue an appeal to the European Court of Human Rights.

“The right to report information has an expiry date just like milk, yoghurt or a pint of ice cream,” fumed Italian media lawyer Guido Scorza in L’Espresso (July 1). “The feeling is that there is still a long way to go to reconcile the right to be forgotten with freedom of the press, and to better balance the interest of the individual and that of the community. Perhaps the time has come for each of us to learn to live with our own past, because otherwise, what awaits us is a future devoid of the collective memory that nurtured democracy along the centuries.”

Google confirmed earlier this year that it would be using geo-location to ascertain a search user is in the European Union to apply requested website index removals. French data protection agency CNIL set a €100,000 fine against Google for failing to remove links to web pages worldwide, “beyond the normal jurisdiction of French and European authorities,” reported Les Echos (September 21). Google, mounting a flotilla of lawyers, asked the French State Council to annul the fine.

 


See also in ftm Knowledge

Press/Media Freedom - Challenges and Concerns

Press and media freedom worldwide is facing challenges from many corners. As authoritarian leaders impose strict control over traditional and new media with impunity, media watchers have concerns for democracy. This ftm Knowledge file accounts the troubles of this difficult decade. 88 pages. PDF (December 2011)

Order here

ftm resources



related ftm articles:

Trying to Stall The Future Never Works
Imagination is not something that can be bottled up and sold over the counter. It is impossible to contain, knows no boundaries, accepts few rules. Those who try always fall short simply because competitive imagination a force that binds us to human nature. It can be very frightening… and that’s good.

The Culture Of Journalism Prevents Forgetting
Journalists do have a way with words. It is their claim to fame, at least for those fortunate enough to find a bit. They are, understandably, sensitive to public perception of the Fourth Estate role and their position in it. Paper and ink journalism isn’t what the used to be. Today we might say “never pick a fight with someone who buys bandwidth by the terabyte.”

Clouds, Cookies, Rules And Confusion
A cloud hovers over the technology horizon at this very moment. All those clever IT engineers have created such joy, not to forget opportunities for commerce, that new rules are needed to keep it all from being so overwhelming. Big changes are in store for the web, some lovely, some weird and all challenging.


advertisement

ftm Knowledge

Media in Spain - Diverse and Challenged – new

Media in Spain is steeped in tradition. yet challenged by diversity. Publishers hold great influence, broadcasters competing. New media has been slow to rise and business models for all are under stress. Rich in language and culture, Spain's media is reaching into the future and finding more than expected. 123 pages, PDF. January 2018

Order here

The Campaign Is On - Elections and Media

Elections campaigns are big media events. Candidates and issues are presented, analyzed and criticized in broadcast and print. Media is now more of a participant in elections than ever. This ftm Knowledge file reports on news coverage, advertising, endorsements and their effect on democracy at work. 84 pages. PDF (September 2017)

Order here

Fake News, Hate Speech and Propaganda

The institutional threat of fake news, hate speech and propaganda is testing the mettle of those who toil in news media. Those three related evils are not new, by any means, but taken together have put the truth and those reporting it on the back foot. Words matter. This ftm Knowledge file explores that light. 48 pages, PDF (March 2017)

Order here

More ftm Knowledge files here

Become an ftm Individual or Corporate Member to order Knowledge Files at no charge. JOIN HERE!

copyright ©2004-2016 ftm partners, unless otherwise noted Contact UsSponsor ftm